Make Up After a Fight Game
Twenty-nine questions about how you argue, apologize, and come back together—for couples who want to fight better, not less.
What were you really upset about underneath the thing we were arguing about?
What is the Make Up After a Fight Game?
The Make Up After a Fight Game is a set of prompts couples answer once an argument is over, to talk through what happened instead of who was right.
Instead of replaying who said what, they focus on how the fight happened—what triggered it, what each partner needed, and what an apology actually looked like.
The Make Up After a Fight Game applies this with 29 prompts about conflict style, repair, and boundaries.
How to play
Wait until you're both calm
This works best once the argument itself is over, not mid-fight. Come back to it when you're both actually ready to talk.
Take turns reading the prompt
One card, one question, out loud—Partner 1, then Partner 2.
Answer honestly, then pass it back
Sit with the answers before you move on. There's no rush, and no scoring.
Ready to give it a try?
Looking for couple games to play after an argument? Start whenever you're both ready to talk.
When to use these questions
Right after the fight, still a little raw
Start light—the This or That prompts ease back into talking without reopening the argument.
A day or two later, both calm
Go deeper with the fill-in-the-blank prompts about what you each need to move on.
The same fight keeps happening
Use the boundary and past-relationship-habit questions to name the pattern, not just this one fight.
Why couples play the Make Up After a Fight Game
To talk about the fight itself
Most couples skip straight to an apology or a distraction and never actually discuss what happened. These questions make space to talk through the fight itself, not just move past it.
To catch the pattern, not just the moment
The same disagreement tends to repeat with the same triggers and the same responses. Naming the pattern here makes it easier to catch earlier next time, instead of relitigating it every few weeks.
To rebuild closeness on purpose
Feeling like a team again after conflict doesn't happen automatically just because the yelling stopped. These prompts give you a deliberate way back to each other, instead of waiting it out.
To learn what repair actually looks like
One partner might need words, the other might need time or a small gesture. These questions surface what "sorry" really needs to include for each of you, not just what feels natural to say.
To make the next fight shorter
A fight that's been properly talked through tends to need less rehashing next time something similar comes up—you've already named what it was actually about.
To fight fair going forward
Understanding your own conflict patterns, and your partner's, makes it easier to argue about the actual issue in front of you instead of every old wound it reminds you of.
Explore more couple games
More Start Over games
Reconnect After a Rough Patch: Questions for Couples
Gottman-informed questions for rebuilding trust and closeness after a rough patch.
PlayFind your next conversation
The Make Up After a Fight Game is one of Love Daring's games for couples working through a rough patch, part of the two-game Start Over collection.
All 29 questions in this game
- 01What were you really upset about underneath the thing we were arguing about?
- 02What's the difference between an apology that lands for you and one that doesn't?
- 03What would "we handled that well" have looked like for this fight?
- 04What's a physical sign you can read on me that means I'm shutting down, before I even know it myself?
- 05What do you wish I'd asked you before jumping to explaining my side?
- 06What's a fight from years ago that we'd handle differently today -- what changed?
- 07What do you need from me in the first five minutes after we've both cooled off?
- 08What's something about how your parents fought (or avoided fighting) that shows up in how you fight with me?
- 09Fill in the blank: "What made it worse was when I ___."
- 10Fill in the blank: "I shut down or get defensive when ___."
- 11Fill in the blank: "One thing that would help me cool off faster is ___."
- 12Fill in the blank: "Next time we start heading toward this fight again, I want us to ___."
- 13Guess It: what do you think was the exact sentence that made things worse?
- 14Guess It: what do you think would have stopped this fight from happening in the first place?
- 15Guess It: what do you think I do right after a fight that you wish I'd do sooner?
- 16Guess It: what do you think this fight was really about, underneath the surface topic?
- 17This or That: talk it out immediately, or sleep on it and revisit tomorrow?
- 18This or That: a long hug, or a long conversation, to know we're really okay?
- 19This or That: rehash exactly what was said, or just agree to move forward?
- 20This or That: process it together right away, or each cool off alone first?
- 21Fill in the blank: "The thing I'm proudest of in how we handle conflict is ___."
- 22Fill in the blank: "After a fight, I need ___ before I can move on."
- 23Guess It: what do you think I'd change about how we handle arguments?
- 24What's the thing I do during an argument that you've already clocked as "my move"?
- 25What does "being on the same team" look like in a moment where our interests actually conflict?
- 26What's a boundary you've had to learn to set in relationships, the hard way?
- 27What's a way you know the difference between compromise and quietly losing yourself?
- 28What's a habit from a past relationship you're actively trying to unlearn?
- 29This or That: would you rather I chase you when you pull away, or give you space?
Frequently asked questions
No—jump straight in, no account needed. One of you opens Make Up After a Fight Game and you play together from there, in person or on a call.
Ready to talk it through?
One of Love Daring's games for couples to play when you're ready to talk it through—29 questions, no scorekeeping, at your own pace.
Play the Make Up After a Fight Game